The DB Funding Code – one year on
For well-funded schemes who already have a settled journey plan and objectives, the new regime may not have a great deal of impact on the outcome of the valuation, but the new requirements do impact on the essential valuation building blocks. For those with more challenging funding levels or less settled plans for the future, there is more work to do to comply and quite a few new concepts to grapple with. The key message is to start planning early and undertake training on what the new requirements really mean for you so that the valuation building blocks are in place and well understood ahead of the initial numbers. Early employer engagement is also a good idea to address any employer concerns.
The “new” DB funding code came into force around a year ago. With many trustees and employers beginning to undertake their first valuations under new regime we have outlined key elements trustees should consider as part of this process.
Training
Trustees must understand the new requirements, with support from their advisers. While for many years the trustees’ first concern was addressing ongoing funding deficits, in a world where the Regulator has estimated that over 75% of schemes are in surplus on a low dependency basis, many trustees are switching their attention to options for the future of the scheme. The new regime requires a focus on both ongoing funding and future long-term funding. Understanding what is needed to comply with the funding requirements and planning ahead accordingly are vital.
Long term strategy
Trustees are now required formally to set out for the Regulator how they intend benefits to be provided over the long-term – their “funding target”. Run on, insurance buy-out, or move to a consolidator – which is it? There are many options to consider and whatever the trustees decide they will need to declare in their strategy statement. Whilst this decision is not “fixed in stone”, changes in future will need to be explained.
This plan must be included in the statement of strategy that must be agreed between the trustees and the employer, so it is imperative that trustees engage with employers early and the strategy set is a collaborative one.
Some employers are nervous about locking into a future buy-out strategy, which will be a few years down the line, due to a concern that this could place undue strain on them financially at a time of economic uncertainty. Whilst the strategy can be changed there is a fear that this will be closely questioned by the Regulator in practice, and a run on strategy to low dependency is a safer bet. The decision to move to a buy-out strategy can come later.
Covenant
The shorthand single covenant rating (e.g. tending to strong or weak) that was used in the previous funding regime has been replaced and some explicit covenant review is now a legal requirement. While this doesn’t always require external covenant advice, most trustees will struggle to comply without it. Trustees will need to consider both the “reliability period” (the timeframe over which the trustees could be reasonably certain the company will be able to put money into the scheme) and “covenant longevity” (the period in which the trustees can reasonably conclude the employer will stand behind the scheme). The Regulator considers that, for most employers, covenant longevity will not exceed 10 years, so this will help form a baseline for the assessment.
To assess covenant over the long term will require more holistic data about the employer, not just predicted cash flows over the short term. It will need employers to provide information such as the company’s long term business plan, forward looking prospects, and ESG factors. Trustees and their advisers will need to consider the employer’s resilience in different macroeconomic environments. This is critical in setting the pace of funding into the scheme and how much weight the trustee can place on the employer covenant when setting its long-term strategy.
The Regulator has also said that where employers are not willing to be collaborative and share information with the trustees, they should reduce their reliance on covenant when setting investment and funding strategies – which may mean more money up front for employers. So, they have an incentive to provide information! This is a more nuanced approach to covenant, but in many respects is long overdue as this approach to the future tilts more towards the “real world” future.
Contingent support – look through guarantees
The Regulator’s expectations for contingent assets, in particular what it considers “gold standard” guarantees seem to have changed. Prior to the Code being published, PPF section 75 guarantees were normally considered the best guarantee a scheme could get (other than possibly Crown guarantees).
Now the Regulator seems to indicate “look through guarantees” will be the best guarantee a scheme can have. The requirements that the Regulator describes for such guarantees are wide and include a legal mechanism for trustees to look through to the guarantor’s cash flows when setting contributions, and no onerous conditions attached that could compromise the trustees or the Regulator’s powers (which might in the past have included financial caps, time limits or mutual obligations around investment strategy). The guidance on what this means in practice and what the Regulator will accept meets these requirements is currently limited. We consider there to be few guarantees which will meet the look through guarantee standard, without amendment, including PPF section 75 guarantees.
That is not to say that if trustees don’t have a look though guarantee they can’t place any value on the guarantee they have, but they will need to carefully consider any guarantee from the employer and what the scheme support it provides means. It may mean re-assessing the level of funding/investment risk that the guarantee can support, or it could be a simple question of tweaking an information sharing protocol to more closely align with the guidance.
This is an area where some of what the Regulator seems to expect goes beyond what most employer groups will be willing to give. The PPF standard guarantee is already considered a very tough set of terms so hardening them further seems counter-productive, particularly for schemes where the guarantees remain important due to a weak statutory employer.
Journey Planning
Trustees are required to set a funding and investment strategy that includes a journey plan, explaining how their scheme will move from its current funding position to being fully funded on a low dependency basis by its relevant date, if not already there. Trustees have to consider and document the funding of the scheme and investment strategy together so there is an integrated approach.
For schemes that are already fully funded on a low dependency basis, the Regulator has made clear trustees still need to consider covenant and recognise the macroeconomic uncertainty that continues to impact scheme investments and the employer covenant in different ways. Trustees should stress test their funding under different risks and the potential impact this could have on the scheme’s investment strategy and the underlying employer covenant. So don’t assume there is very limited ongoing work for trustees even in a good funding position.
A key point to note about investment strategy is that whilst there is an obligation to work up what the strategy would look like at low dependency, there is no obligation to invest in line with that strategy, and by the time a scheme reaches low dependency the valuation strategy may well be inappropriate.




