NEWS   |    April 13, 2026

3i v Decesare – a further move away from Courage?

Since Re Courage, nearly 40 years ago, there have been a number of cases that have considered the meaning of specific restrictions in amendment powers, including Walker Morris Trustees Ltd v Masterson IMG Pension Plan HR Trustees Ltd and Briggs and others v Gleeds (Head Office) and others.

In Re Courage the amendment power prohibited amendments which “vary or affect any benefits already secured by past contributions”. The court held this proviso allowed members to retain their final salary link, until they left employment.  Similarly, in Gleeds the High Court held that an amendment power preventing alterations that would “prejudice or impair the benefits accrued in respect of membership up to that time” prevented the removal of a final salary link.

These cases have all concluded, for different reasons, that a restriction in an amendment power which refers to “secured” or “accrued” means that members must remain entitled to a pension based on the member’s final salary so long as they continue to be employed by their Employer. In other words, this restriction prevents amendments being made to a scheme that break the final salary link, on scheme closure or otherwise, so these benefits will continue to enjoy a final salary underpin.

British Broadcasting Corporation v BBC Pension Trust Limited 2024 went further and held that an “interests” restriction in the amendment power without any clear temporal limitation not only meant that you could not break the final salary link, but it also prevented amendments to stop future accrual of benefits.

However, since BBC there have been a few cases which indicate that we may be moving away from the analysis in the Courage line of cases. Avon and Newell, which were both in quick succession in 2024, were the first of such cases.

A move away from Courage?

In Avon the key issue was whether a benefit change from DB to CARE was valid. The amendment power did not allow alterations which “affect prejudicially … benefits accrued or secured up to the date on which the amendment takes effect … “.

The amendment to the scheme produced two categories of members. The “Revaluation Winners”, those who were better off as a result of the CARE amendment – the revaluation of their accrued benefits gave a higher benefit than final salary linkage. The “FS Winners”, those whose benefits would be higher by applying final salary linkage.

The court was told that a compromise had been agreed in relation to the Final Salary Winners. Members had been given 70% of the difference between benefits on a revaluation basis and the benefits on a final salary basis.  This was decided on the basis that there was a 30% chance of success of the arguments that the company had put forward against a Courage analysis.

In short, the judge held that this split was appropriate. If the Courage line of cases had been applied strictly, arguably the Final Salary Winners should have received the full final salary underpin. So, there is a subtle move away from Courage here.

In Newell [2024] the scheme moved from DB benefits to DC benefits and accrued rights were converted without consent in 1992. The restriction in the amendment power provided that no alteration could “prejudice or impair the benefits accrued in respect of membership“.

Green J was troubled by cases such as IMG (which had imposed a final salary underpin on a conversion from DB to DC benefits) stating that he was unclear what the juridical basis for the imposition of an underpin by the Courts. If the conversion from DB to DC breached the restriction it meant there was no power to make amendments to the scheme and they were ultra vires.

He therefore did not follow IMG and came up with a different calculation for addressing the restriction in the amendment power, essentially a calculation based on actuarial assumptions made in 1992, taking into account the data available.

Whilst the judge did not say that Courage was wrong, he did come up with a calculation to compensate for the move away from DB accrual which was not an underpin to the benefit. This is arguably another move away from the strict application of the Courage and  Gleeds line of cases.

3i v Decesare

In 3i [2025] the scheme closed to future accrual in 2010. The restriction in the amendment power stated no amendments could “… diminish any pension already being paid under the Plan or the accrued rights or interests of any Member or other person in respect of benefits already provided under the Plan …”  (our emphasis). At the time of the closure the final salary underpin had been maintained so the judge was not asked to consider the underpin directly.

Instead, as mentioned above, the court was asked to consider if the reference to “interests” in the amendment power had to be interpreted in accordance with the analysis in BBC i.e. that the amendment power prevented amendments to stop future accrual of benefits completely.

Richard Smith J in 3i stated that “interests” will depend on the context and terms of each amendment power. There was a temporal limitation in the 3i amendment power and so it followed that the fetter had not prevented the parties from closing the scheme to future accrual. His view was that there was nothing in the surrounding context – such as the way the words “interests” and “rights” were used elsewhere in the plan’s governing documents which would justify an alternative conclusion.

Whilst 3i does not supersede the BBC case as the restrictions in the amendment power are different, it is helpful to know that there can be an alternative interpretation of “interests” and that the Courage restrictions did not prevent a scheme from closing to future accrual and winding up.

Key takeaways

It is worth noting that all these cases are first instance judgements, so this issue has not, yet, been considered by the court of appeal. However, where previously there was a “Courage style” amendment power in a scheme trustees, employers and legal advisers have been required to adopt a cautious approach to breaking the link with final salary. In light of cases such as Avon, Newell and 3i, a more robust approach may be more defensible, taking into account the specific restrictions in the scheme’s amendment power, and the use of language will be key.

Kate and Archana’s article was originally published in Professional Pensions, here.

The views in this article are intended for general information purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for professional advice. Arc Pensions Law and the author(s) are not responsible for any direct or indirect result arising from any reliance placed on content, including any loss, and exclude liability to the full extent. Always seek appropriate legal advice from a suitably qualified lawyer before taking, or avoiding taking, any action. If you have any questions on the points raised in the above, please do not hesitate to get in touch.

Related News